By Amir H.

The air smelled like wet bark and old pennies.

Sheriff Dominique Williams stood at the edge of the playground, the light from her cruiser casting a slow, rhythmic strobe across the empty swings. A fine drizzle clung to the trees lining the Chattahoochee RiverWalk, softening the world in fog and yellow pollen. The scar along her neck ached. She didn’t like it here—not after dark, not after watching that footage.

She tried to think back to better days—her two daughters playing at this very park. It looked different then: soft woodchips instead of the shredded rubber pellets they used now. A rusted metal slide was replaced with bright plastic tubes. All part of Remington’s grand revitalization project.

Paint over rot.

“Want to enter Plushy’s world?” she whispered, almost involuntarily.

The phrase had come from a grainy Hi8 tape—one of those old Sony camcorders that needed rewinding. Dominique had to dust off the department’s A/V relics just to get it to play. The tape belonged to a man named Calvin Reece, the grandfather of a missing girl named Teagan. Nineteen years old. Gone for four days now. Last seen filming a TikTok challenge at this very playground.

Plushy offerings, they called it.

It bothered Dominique how easily these kids flirted with the devil.

On-screen, Calvin wandered the playground like a ghost in denim, muttering to himself, to Teagan, to something else.

“I know you took her, you demon. You took my grandbaby. I want her back.”

His voice cracked as he waved a Tickle Me Elmo doll in his hand. He climbed the stairs to the top of the tunnel slide. Then he looked straight into the lens.

“I, Calvin Reece, am recording this in hopes someone finds it and stops this monster. It feeds off despair. Off tragedy. But I refuse to let it have my baby.”

Then he threw the Elmo doll down the slide.

What scared Dominique wasn’t what she saw.
It was what she didn’t.

The Tickle Me Elmo never came out the other side.

On the tape, Calvin waited. Checked the bottom of the slide. Nothing. Then he whispered a short prayer—asking God for strength—and crawled in after it.

Given his six-foot frame, he should’ve slid out in seconds.

But he didn’t.

The tunnel felt… endless. Calvin stopped halfway, turned, and tried to climb back up. That’s when the sound started. A faint, tumbling noise echoing down the plastic.

And then a voice:

“Wanna play? Plushies like to play…”

The camera couldn’t catch what spoke, but something about it made Calvin hesitate—then in a frantic slide deeper in. Something was coming. Something giggling.

Eventually, the footage resumed with Calvin stumbling out the end of the tunnel—only now it wasn’t the playground anymore.

The camera lay sideways, capturing shaky, blurry footage as he pulled a flashlight from his pocket. Concrete walls. Rusted bars. A wet floor. He was in what looked like a sewage tunnel.

At the far end sat the Elmo toy in a folding chair. Its battery-powered laugh echoed off the walls.

“Heeheehee! Elmo loves you!”

The flashlight began to flicker.

Just behind the toy, something shifted in the dark.

From the edges of the tunnel, long, mummified hands began to stretch into the frame, twitching, shivering, crawling along the walls.

And just before the light died completely, the camera caught a blur of something stepping forward—something gaunt and ghoulish, with one glowing blue eye. The other eye was a hollow crater.

Dominique shivered.

She reached into her coat pocket and pulled out an evidence bag. Inside: a waterlogged Elmo doll, its stitched eyes loose, soaked in something dark.

It had been found at the bottom of the same slide.

But not by her deputies.

By morning joggers.
At a different park.
Across town.
Lying beside the drowned body of Calvin Reece.
And his water-damaged camcorder.

---

A week later, the footage went viral.
Not Calvin’s tape—but Teagan Reece’s.

It leaked from her TikTok account, even though she’d been missing for days.
At first, just static. Then the Elmo doll—but not the same one Calvin threw.
Then the tunnel.
Then—
A shriek. A flash of blue light. A single glowing eye.

Comments flooded in:

“Fake af.”
“Omg where is this?? 😱”
“Let’s do the Plushy Slide in my town lol”

The video hit 2.6 million views in four hours.
And then kids started disappearing again.

That night, Dominique parked at the playground once more.

The tunnel slide gleamed wet beneath the moonlight.
No laughter. No cameras. No wind.
Just her—and the memory of what she’d seen.

She placed a worn teddy bear at the mouth of the slide.
Amber’s. Her youngest daughter’s.

“Want to enter Plushy’s world?” she said.

The bear vanished. No sound. No trace.
Dominique stared.
Then, without her radio, without backup, she climbed to the top.
She whispered the same prayer Calvin had.
For strength. For protection. For mercy.

And then—
She slid.The dashcam on her cruiser kept recording.
A minute passed.
Then five.
Then ten.
But she never came out the other end.

---

For more Southern gothic stories woven in memory and myth, discover Rose Red Snow: A Southern Gothic Horror Novella